top of page

We Didn’t Work Out. Five Years Later, We Did.

Anonymous
By Anonymous

Love, in its usual telling, follows a linear path: two people meet, fall in love, face a few obstacles, and settle into “happily ever after.” But my love story never fit that mold. My relationship with Theo has been more like a sprawling tree than a straight line, with branches that twisted, doubled back, and grew in unexpected directions. Somehow, all the turns and detours made it into something I can’t imagine living without.


I met Theo in college. I was twenty, fresh from a high school romance that was more about convenience than connection. Theo sat two rows ahead of me in history class, always scribbling notes with this intense focus. It made him mysterious, like he carried a hidden past. I liked how unapproachable he seemed. He was just out of reach, and that made me want to try.


Our connection started slowly. We were friends at first, meeting up for study sessions and late-night coffees. Theo had a way of listening that made me feel truly seen, which was a rare feeling for me back then. In his presence, I could be softer, a little more myself. Our friendship deepened, and the line between friendship and something more was slowly blurring. I knew I was falling for him, and I thought that maybe he felt the same. But there was a strange hesitation on his part, like he was holding something back.


Then, one day, he was gone—not physically, but emotionally. Our conversations grew shorter, and his laughter was guarded. Theo was distancing himself. I didn’t know how to ask what had changed, and I suppose I was afraid of what he might say. Eventually, we drifted apart. There was no dramatic fight, no specific reason. Just a painful silence that settled between us.


I moved on, convinced that he was simply a “what if” in my life. I dated other people, and had relationships that were steady, educational—even serious. But Theo remained this unfinished story in my mind, a piece of my past that I couldn’t quite put away. I thought I had loved him, but maybe it was just a youthful infatuation that hadn’t worked out. With time, I let go of our story, letting him drift further back into my memory.


But, five years later, I ran into him. I was browsing a bookstore, minding my own business, when we both reached for the same book. My heart skipped as if I’d seen a ghost. He was different—there was gray in his hair, an added seriousness in his eyes—but that familiar intensity was still there. We struck up a conversation, one that stretched over coffee, then dinner. Theo explained the reason he had pulled away back in college: a family illness took over his life, and this made him feel like he couldn’t handle a relationship. He apologized for disappearing, for not trusting me with the truth.


Hearing him out, I felt a strange sense of relief. Maybe I could have helped him back then, but maybe I couldn’t have. I was young and I barely knew myself back then, still learning what I wanted and who I wanted to be. It occurred to me that maybe I, too, hadn’t been ready for him when we first met. The past few years had taught me things I hadn’t understood about love or about myself.


We started seeing each other again. It wasn’t instant or easy. There were scars from our time apart, hesitations and doubts that made us tread carefully. We were different people, and learning each other all over again was both familiar and foreign. When we reconnected, Theo had developed a new habit of tapping his fingers rhythmically on the table when he spoke, a sign of his heightened energy or maybe just a nervous quirk he’d picked up over the years. He still had that intense way of listening—his head slightly tilted, his eyes locked on mine, as if nothing else in the world mattered but what I was saying. It was the same quiet attentiveness that had drawn me to him in college. Our dates were quieter, more reflective, and filled with real conversations about who we were, or who we wanted to be. I found myself drawn to Theo in a new way, without the urgency or idealization of the past. Now, I saw him as he was, not as the mystery I wanted to unravel.


It wasn’t a fairy tale reunion. We had challenging conversations about our past, the time we lost, and whether we could really move forward together. Loving him meant not only facing our shared past, but also the parts of us that had grown and changed while we were apart. Sometimes I wondered if love was supposed to be this complicated—wasn’t it supposed to be easy If it was meant to be? But then I’d look at Theo, and I’d feel this quiet certainty. Life had given us a second chance, and despite the messy past, I didn’t want to waste it trying to force a neat, linear story.


One night as we sat on his balcony watching the city lights, Theo asked me if I regretted the years we’d lost. I didn’t need to think before answering. No, I told him. Those years taught me things about myself I could not have learned any other way. And without that time apart, I’m not sure we would have found our way back to each other as the people we had become. I realized then that loving him wasn’t about what might have been, fantasizing about his mystique–it was about what was right here, right now.


Our love isn’t perfect. It ebbs and flows, sometimes as fragile as glass, other times as solid as oak. We argue, we disagree, and we stumble through the challenges that come with building a life together. But I’ve come to see that love isn’t always a straight line. Ours stretches and bends, sometimes doubling back, sometimes blazing new trails.


People often talk about finding the “right” person as if love is a matter of fixed variables, a formula. But my relationship with Theo has taught me that love is less about perfection and more about choosing each other, despite the messiness and detours. Ours might not be a traditional love story, but I wouldn’t change a single twist in the path. I feel truer to who we are, flaws and all, than any fairy tale ever could.

18 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

コメント


bottom of page